موقف الاستشراق المعاصر من علم الكلام الإسلامي (فرقة المعتزلة أنموذجا)

- دراسة تحليليّة ومقارنة في نماذج مختارة من المستشرقين المعاصرين – (هنري كوربان ، هاري.أوسترين.ولفسون، مونتغمري وات)

المؤلفون

  • Hala Kadhim Saloomi Imam Al-Kadhim College / Department of Quran and Hadith Science

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.31973/aj.v2i139.2632

الكلمات المفتاحية:

الاستشراق المعاصر، علم الكلام الإسلامي، فرقة المعتزلة أنموذجا، نماذج من المستشرقين، هنري كوربان، هاري، أوسترين، ولفسون، مونتغمري وات

الملخص

    شغل علم الكلام الإسلامي ، وبضمنه فرقة المعتزلة اهتماما بالغاً لدى المستشرقين منذ تعرفهم على الفكر الإسلامي ، واليوم  ومع الاستشراق المعاصر نجد يتجه ذلك الاهتمام نحو التزايد محاولا التخلص من المقولات السابقة التي أغلبها تأطرت بايدلوجيا الفوقية الغربية، ليكشف من جديد عن أهم المؤثرات الخارجية والثقافية والاجتماعية وبشكل أكثر دقة عن ماهية المضمون الذاتي لعلم الكلام الإسلامي ،  وسنرى أن هذه المعالجة الجديدة للأنساق الكلامية ، لا تشكل  أي انعطافة عن مسار سابقيهم من المستشرقين ، إذ أبقوا على ذات المنهجية من التأثر والتأثير ، والمنهج الفرضي الاستنباطي ، أو منهج التخمين وإلى غيرها .تلك المقولات التي انصبت في قوالب و صيغ عدة ، فيمكن عدّها حقا امتدادا  لسلفها ، وبالتالي لم يسعهم الاستغناء عما ردّده الاستشراق القديم.

التنزيلات

تنزيل البيانات ليس متاحًا بعد.

المراجع

The Holy Quran

Abd al-Majid Muhammad al-Waalan: The Position of Orientalists on the Mu'tazila, (Summary of a Message) by Mansour Abd al-Aziz al-Juhaili

Abd al-Qadir al-Baghdadi: The difference between the sects, Takhfeq: Muhammad Muhyi al-Din, Beirut, Dar al-Maarifa.

Abd al-Rahman Badawi: Encyclopedia of Orientalists, Beirut, 3rd Edition, Dar Al-Ilm for the Millions, 1993.

Abdul Karim Al-Afani: Justice in theology, article, August 12, 2020.

Abdullah Abdul Rahman Al-Wahaibi: On the New Orientalism, Preliminary Introductions. I 1, 1435 AH, King Fahd Library.

Abdullah Al-Amiri_Ahmed Al-Zebibi: The Mu’tazila’s Position on the Verses of the Attributes of God Almighty (a critical study), Damascus University Journal of Economic and Legal Sciences, Volume 28, Issue 2, 2012.

Ahmed Ghorab: An Islamic View of Orientalism. Within the comprehensive library website.

Ahmed Salim Askif: The Orientalist Harry Wolfson Approach in the Philosophy of the Speakers, Risalah, Damascus, 2016.

Albert Hourani: Islam in European Thought, Beirut, 1994.

Ali Al-Maghrabi: Islamic Theological Differences, Wahba Library, Cairo.

Al-Shahristani: Al-Milal and Al-Nahl, three parts, investigated by: Abdul Aziz Muhammad Al-Wakeel, Cairo, Al-Halabi Foundation

Edward Said: Orientalism, knowledge, authority, creation, by Kamal Abu Deeb, 1978, Arab Research Foundation.

Encyclopedia of Faith: Book Seven, Faith in Destiny and Destiny, General Supervisor: Alawi bin Abdul Qadir Al-Saqqaf, Plat T, Al-Durar Al-Sunni website

Explanation of the Five Principles, by Judge Abdul-Jabbar, investigation: Abdul-Karim Othman, Cairo, 3rd Edition.

Fath Al-Din Muhammad Abu Al-Fath Al-Bayanouni: An Introduction to Contemporary Orientalism and Modern Science. King Fahd National Library, Riyadh, 1433 AH.

Haider Qasim Matar Al-Tamimi: Islamic Theology in the Studies of German Orientalists, House of Wisdom, Baghdad.

Hanim Ibrahim Youssef: The Origin of Justice for the Mu'tazila. Arab Thought House, Cairo, 1993.

Hassan Qasim Murad: The beginnings of Islamic theology, a critique of the views of Yusef van Ase. T: Haider Qassem Matar Al-Tamimi. Oriental Studies Journal, Issue 18, 2019.

Henry Corbin: A History of Islamic Philosophy, T.: Nasir Marwa and Hassan Kobeisy, Beirut, Oweidat Publishing, 2nd Edition, 1998.

Ibn Khaldun: Introduction, investigation: Abdullah Muhammad Al-Darwish, Volume 3, Edition 1, Damascus, 2004, Dar Yarub.

Ismail Shaker Al-Rifai: Political topics and research, Journal: Al-Hiwar Al-Modundan, Issue 6298, 2019.

Jamil Hamdaoui: Orientalism, desirability, Arabization and Occidentalism (a conceptual approach). Oriental Studies Journal, No. 19, 2019, the Islamic Center for Strategic Studies.

Johann Fock: History of the Orientalist Movement: Arab and Islamic Studies in Europe until the Beginning of the Twentieth Century, translated by: Omar Lutfi Al-Alam, 2nd Edition, Al-Madar Al-Islami Publications, 2001.

Judge Abdul-Jabbar: Al-Mughni in the Doors of Justice and Unity, 1st Edition, Cairo, 1960, Dar Al-Irshad.

Kamal Muhammad Ali: Readings in the Arab and Islamic Thought, Al-Hiwar Al-Modundan Magazine, Issue 4755, 2015.

Khaled Abdel Moneim: Modern Orientalism: Its Fields and Scientific Methodology, article.

Majid Fakhri: History of Islamic Philosophy, From the Eighth Century to the Present Day, T: Kamal Al-Yazji, Beirut, Edition 2, 2000.

Mazen Mutabaqani: Has Orientalism ended? article.

Minhaj as-Sunnah, Part 1, Ibn Taymiyyah, investigation: Muhammad Rashad, Saud University, 1986.

Montgomery Watt: Judgment and Predestination in the Dawn of Islam and Over the First Three Centuries, T: Abdul Rahman Abdullah Al Sheikh, Cairo, 1998

Montgomery Watt: The Group and the Difference, an article, translated by: Nahida Jaafar.

Muhammad Khalifa Hassan: The Crisis of Modern and Contemporary Orientalism.

Nabih Bashir: Jewish Theology, Encyclopedia of Mediterranean Tendency, Houari, Touati, 2018.

Nasr Hamid Abu Zaid: The Mental Attitude in Interpretation..A Study in the Case of Metaphor in the Qur'an for the Mu'tazilites. 1st floor, Beirut, Dar Al-Tanweer for printing, 1982.

Olivier Mouss: The New Orientalism and Islam - From the Communist East to the Islamic East, T.: Omariya Soltani, 1st Edition, Bibliotheca Alexandrina, 2010.

Rawaa Mahmoud: The Problem of Text and Reason in Islamic Philosophy, Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiyya, Beirut, 2006.

Saad Abdullah Ashour: The Position of the Islamic Sects on the Actions of the People, Journal of the Islamic University, Gaza, Palestine, Volume 9, Issue 2, 2001.

Saeb Abdel Hamid: Doctrines and Differences in Islam, Origins and Landmarks, 1st Edition, Al-Risala Publications.

Salem Hajj Sassi: Criticism of Orientalist Discourse: The Orientalist Phenomenon and Its Impact on Islamic Studies, 1st Edition, Islamic Orient Publications, 2002 AD.

Salima Juma'a Ali al-Mushaiti: The position of the Orientalist Harry A. Wolfson on the issue of divine attributes in Islamic theology. Issue 8, 2017, part 4.

Shafia Seddik: In Philosophy of Religion, an Applied Study, Contemporary Jewish Theology and Orientalism Harry Wolfson, Algeria, April, 2020, Article: within Dr. Shafia’s website.

The Greek Heritage in Islamic Civilization, Studies by Senior Orientalists, T: Rahman Badawi, Kuwait, 4th edition.

Those who went to extremes in denying fate and they are fatalism: A group of authors, Journal of Islamic Research, Issue 34, 2016.

Wolfson A. Harry: The Philosophy of the Speakers, Volume 1, T: Mustafa Labib Abdel Ghani, 2nd Edition, Cairo, 2009

Wolfson A. Harry: The Philosophy of the Speakers, Volume 2, T: Mustafa Labib Abdel Ghani, 2nd Edition, Cairo, 2009.

Zachary Lockman: The History and Politics of Orientalism: The Struggle for Interpreting the Middle East, T: Sherif Younes, 2nd Edition, Dar Al-Shorouk, 2008.

Zuhdi Jarallah: The Mu'tazila, Beirut, 6th edition, The Arab Foundation, 1990.

التنزيلات

منشور

2021-12-15

إصدار

القسم

علم الفلسفة

كيفية الاقتباس

موقف الاستشراق المعاصر من علم الكلام الإسلامي (فرقة المعتزلة أنموذجا): - دراسة تحليليّة ومقارنة في نماذج مختارة من المستشرقين المعاصرين – (هنري كوربان ، هاري.أوسترين.ولفسون، مونتغمري وات). (2021). مجلة الآداب, 2(139), 475-498. https://doi.org/10.31973/aj.v2i139.2632

تواريخ المنشور

المؤلفات المشابهة

1-10 من 720

يمكنك أيضاً إبدأ بحثاً متقدماً عن المشابهات لهذا المؤلَّف.